Michigan Small Farm Council
  • Home
  • Join Us
  • Legal Resources
  • Small Farm Insurance
  • GAAMPs
  • Blog
  • Calendar
  • Timeline
  • News
  • News & Events
  • Board of Directors
  • Resources
  • FAQs
  • Store
  • Contact
  • Blog

MDARD Confirms that Right to Farm Protects Entire State, Regardless of Zoning

5/9/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
By Wendy Lockwood Banka

Anyone who has followed the work of the Michigan Small Farm Council knows that one of our firmly held beliefs is that the Michigan Right to Farm Act protects farms of all sizes in the state, regardless of size or place, and that this protection preempts local regulations such as zoning.  We think this is true because the law states this clearly, because the Michigan Court of Appeals has three times ruled that farms in residentially-zoned areas are protected by Right to Farm (see Village of Rothbury, Papesh, Papadelis), and because scholars from MSU and MSU-Extension have come to this conclusion in multiple publications. 

Indeed, the only party who appears to be uncertain about this is the Michigan Department of Agriculture and Rural Development.  In 2011 the Director of Environmental Stewardship at MDARD, Jim Johnson, said that "The difficulty of the issue, in terms of legal versus non-legal issues, is that the RTF Act itself does not place a restriction in any way on land use or land zoning.  It has been very clear from the beginning that the RTF Act applies across the entire state."  But then in 2012 MDARD told Forsyth Township that Randy Buchler was not protected on his property that is zoned Lake Residential.  This led to a court case in which Randy Buchler prevailed.  The confusion and ongoing Right to Farm court battles in the state are a direct result of situations like this in which MDARD sometimes advises local governments and citizens that they are not protected by Right to Farm, in situations in which all other authorities - the law, the courts, the legal scholars - all come to the opposite conclusion. 

Since 2012 the Michigan Small Farm Council has engaged in repeated interactions with MDARD and with the Commission of Agriculture and Rural Development over this issue.  We have been told repeatedly that Right to Farm does not protect folks who live in residentially zoned areas of the state.  So it is with surprise that we read this new letter written by Chief Deputy Director Gordon Wenk, which states quite simply, "Since zoning is not a requirement for Right to Farm coverage, the Right to Farm Act applies across the entire state, regardless of zoning."  We agree.  You can find the letter from Mr. Wenk here, and the letter from Brady Township that he was responding to, here.  A longer history of these events is here.

The only question that remains, then, is whether the changes to the 2014 Site Selection GAAMP have the authority to strip the legal protections provided by the legislature:  can five appointed members of the Michigan Commission of Agriculture take any action that would un-do the work of the legislature to provide Right to Farm protection to all Michigan citizens?  We think not, but the battle continues.
0 Comments

FDA Issues Warning Letter to Shur-Green FarmsĀ 

5/7/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
By Wendy Lockwood Banka

Shur-Green Farms has now been issued a warning letter from the FDA for a number of their actions that involved the distribution of lasalocid-contaminated "soyoil" into the animal feed stream.  This letter provides details not previously released, including the fact that Shur-Green first entered into an agreement to collect and transport lascadoil waste beginning in July of 2013.  We now also know that it was a load delivered a year later, on July 30, 2014, that caused the deaths of the 57,700 turkeys on a farm in Michigan.  And, even while these events were unfolding in Michigan, Shur-Green continued to sell the contaminated product to unspecified customers.

0 Comments

Brady Township considers new ordinance to disallow all new commercial agriculture in rural residential areas of two acres or more

5/6/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
By Wendy Lockwood Banka

Brady Township is holding a special meeting tonight to consider proposed amendments to the Brady Township Ordinance, which would completely outlaw all new commercial agriculture in this "rural residential" area of two acres or more.  Details are here.  

1 Comment

    Michigan Small Farm Council

    Welcome to the blog of the Michigan Small Farm Council!  The Michigan Small Farm Council was established to advocate for small-scale farmers in urban, suburban and rural areas throughout Michigan, and to provide educational and information resources to the small farm community.

    Categories

    All
    Workshops & Classes

    Archives

    November 2017
    October 2017
    January 2017
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    May 2014
    April 2013
    March 2013

    RSS Feed

  © 2013 - 2019 Michigan Small Farm Council, All rights reserved.

The Michigan Small Farm Council does not provide legal advice. Any information provided on or by this Web site is not intended to be legal advice, nor is it intended to be a substitute for legal services from a competent professional.